Issues on member Profile Pages
Ning To Jamroom
ChoclateLife says:
"With respect to the Discussions/Groups issue raised above, the issue is even larger and - I think Paul and Douglas - will provide the reason to make the change I ask for. If you read this Strumelia, please chime in.
What's important is context, and that context is complicated through conflating " group_discuss " and " forum ".
On the home page, a mouseover on "All" next to Latest Discussions has the path conclude in " group_discuss ". The path for Discussions in the top nav is " /username/forum ".
This is a problem given that the same word - Discussions - is, to my mind confusingly, used to describe different destinations. I would address this issue by explicitly using the label "Top Group Discussions" and changing "Discussions" to "Forums" in the top nav, As the prototypical user of the site is someone familiar with Ning that differentiation in wording reduces the cognitive burden of switching platforms.
Again, thinking about context. If I am on MY profile page, then clicking on "All" next to Latest Discussions should show MY discussions - the discussions I created and I contributed to - ** IRRESPECTIVE of whether they belong to a group or they are part of the Forum **. They are all discussions with different properties (group ownership or category).
Following through with the home page usage and the wording Latest Discussions, " /group_discuss " would be more logically consistent than " /groups " even though all discussions belong to groups.
Taking this to the next step, if I am looking at any other member's profile clicking on "All" next to Latest Discussions should display all of the discussions that member created and/or contributed to."
====================
Strumelia says: This is the same GroupDiscussions vs ForumDiscussions confusion issue that we've been discussing with Brian over here:
https://www.jamroom.net/the-jamroom-network/forum/new_posts/20131/home-page-replacing-top-discussions-with-forum-newest-posts#last
This is something that is really going to need to be sorted out because it's causing various confusing issues in terms of navigation and expected content. I have noticed the same issue Chocolate is describing- in a profile when clicking on the member's 'discussions'...we get taken to Groups....when in fact we want to see the forum discussions that the member has most recently started....OR, as Choc suggests, we should see the latest Forum AND Group discussions that that member has started. (perhaps with the option of also seeing that member's latest POSTS in Forum Discussions or Forum AND group discussions.
Long story short: We can't keep by passing FORUMS on our sites and pointing only to the discussions within Groups.
updated by @strumelia: 01/02/15 01:00:11PM