Forum
Suggestions
More of a backstage bar/greenroom response than a Suggestions forum response. Sorry.
My first question was "are you moving your community, or starting to build a new one"?
My first thought was that it sounds like you have a forum-style site, IPB is bringing out new features, jrForum doesn't replicate IPB, but you'd like it to because Jamroom is much better (to work with) than IPB (they do different jobs).
My second thought was "What am I saying?": Of course you should go with Jamroom. But important to note that for building a community, Jamroom 5 has a Followers and Profiles emphasis, not a forum emphasis. This here jamroom.net community is based on things other than the forum - the software, and supporting it, and a long history as you know.
Final thought is that you need to base your decision on
1. your available resources (skill, time and/or money),
2. whether or not you can bring your existing communities to the new site (that doesn't involve features or cms's, it's purely down to your skill in moving your users from one of your sites to another and what you say to them to achieve that),
3. Which has the closest feature set to what you require as a forum? (JR or IPB)?
4. Your personal preference - which one is more interesting to you? (JR or IPB?)
I think jr5 is something special (specialler than 4), so I naturally recommend that choice. But if you don't have the resources, can't move your users, or need a traditional stylee forum, then go with IPB or similar.
updated by @ultrajam: 05/24/14 10:51:44AM