User Privacy Settings Don't Seem to Have Right Descriptions
Using Jamroom
davej56:Hey Brian, I'm just not understanding why when I set Linne to Private, even the member profile Dave could not see her at all. I guess what I'm looking for is for Private and Shared profiles to show up as having a profile that you can click on the follow button for, even though you can't actually view the profile until you are approved as a follower. I just want people to be able to search and see, Linne has a profile, and then click on a follow button. Maybe I'm being a bit redundant in what I'm saying, but I hope you get the jest of it.
I understand what you're getting at, but would disagree:
1) If a profile is "private" it should be 100% private. the site owner should not be able to override that.
2) If a profile is "shared" then it should be 100% private to those who are profile owners and followers.
What you're looking for might override what the user wants. What if I want a private profile? Why should my profile image be viewable to anyone? What if I want a profile that is private for just me and my friends? Why should a user I don't know be able to see anything about me? These are the types of privacy "leaks" that has gotten facebook into trouble in the past.
When someone says "private" the expectation should be 100% privacy - this includes not being found.
If someone says "followers only" it should be just that - all items hidden from users who are not admins or followers. Again if the profile wants to be "discoverable" then they need to be global.
What I want to avoid is coding a solution that prevents the user from having final say over their privacy, so if we allow "leaks" like this then the user really does not have control - the site owner has now removed that control from them.
I know that's not what you're looking for, but hopefully you understand why the settings work the way they do. And that's not to say that we can't code in different levels to support what you're looking for - that is just not the way it currently works.