Reversing the order of replies to forum discussion (newest first)
Using Jamroom
Yes, this has been the last step needed for the whole "reverse order in forums' thing to function well. (see my last two posts and my screenshots).
I had been thinking just yesterday about starting a new thread here about just this remaining issue... particularly because this thread is marked 'solved'. But with Elise's new post above, perhaps it can still be a part of completing the project of making the reverse order work well in actual use.
In Group discussions, it all works well simply because group discussions don't use pagination- they use "show more" link at bottom. So technically it's all on one page which can be made longer to show older posts...and thus the original post will always show on top. jrForums however still keep the orig post only on the with the oldest replies. When a discussion gets to be more than 1 page long the orig post gets buried.
It's true that a member who comes to the thread from seeing a new post in activity feed will then not see the orig post and will be in the dark about the actual topic being talked about. As Elise says, they see only the title ...unless they are savvy enough to scroll down and use the pager to get to the oldest page where the orig post resides. This is very problematic, especially on mobile devices.